Can I file a diminished value claim in New York?

Generally yes — if another driver was at fault, New York typically lets you pursue diminished value (the resale value your car lost just from having an accident on its record) against that driver's insurer. Diminished value applies to a repaired car, not a totaled one.

Can I recover diminished value from my own insurer in New York?

Usually not. In New York, as in most states, your own auto policy generally doesn't cover diminished value — it's typically pursued against the at-fault driver's insurer instead.

How long do I have to file a diminished value claim in New York?

In New York the statute of limitations is generally 3 years, and the clock usually starts on the accident date — not when the car was repaired. Waiting too long can permanently bar the claim.

New York · Diminished value

Diminished value claims in New York

If your car was repaired after a crash someone else caused, it's now worth less on paper simply because it has an accident on its record. In New York, that lost value — “diminished value” — can generally be pursued. Here's how New York treats it.

Get started — free

New York at a glance

Third-party DV (at-fault driver's insurer): Yes
First-party DV (your own insurer): No
How DV is measured: Market comparison (before-vs-after value)
Time limit to file (statute of limitations): 3 years

Diminished value in New York

NY Court of Appeals has NOT squarely decided first-party auto DV; first-party DV posture is policy-language dependent — most NY auto policies use ISO 'like kind and quality' / 'repair or replace' language that disables 1P DV (consistent with FL Siegle / TX Pritchett / OH Schaefer). Third-party DV against the tortfeasor IS recoverable under the standard NY tort measure of property damage (full loss including residual diminution); Franklin Corp. v. Prahler, 932 N.Y.S.2d 610 is available as a supporting cite. Acquista is NOT a DV anchor (it is a bad-faith consequential-damages opinion).

The cases that shape DV in New York

Franklin Corp. v. Prahler, 932 N.Y.S.2d 610 (third-party tort-measure DV cite available if needed); NO controlling NY appellate first-party DV authority

How Moe handles diminished value in New York

Knowing the rule is one thing — applying it against a carrier is another. Moe builds your case to New York’s rules, drafts every letter for your approval, tracks the deadlines, and only pings you when there’s a decision to make.

Open my New York case — free See how it works

New York diminished value — common questions

Can I file a diminished value claim in New York?: Generally yes — if another driver was at fault, New York typically lets you pursue diminished value (the resale value your car lost just from having an accident on its record) against that driver's insurer. Diminished value applies to a repaired car, not a totaled one.
Can I recover diminished value from my own insurer in New York?: Usually not. In New York, as in most states, your own auto policy generally doesn't cover diminished value — it's typically pursued against the at-fault driver's insurer instead.
How long do I have to file a diminished value claim in New York?: In New York the statute of limitations is generally 3 years, and the clock usually starts on the accident date — not when the car was repaired. Waiting too long can permanently bar the claim.

Learn more

All New York accident-claim rules · Other states

This page summarizes New York’s car-accident claim rules for general information — it is not legal advice, and the rules can change. What applies to your claim depends on your policy and the specific facts.